Start with Why, not What

—

5–7 minutes
Write the adventure: for travel & adventure writers

Kia ora,

I’m excited to introduce you a guest this week! Esther Harder is a book coach who helps memoir writers with battered passports tell their story on their own terms. She’s here to talk about an essential part of the writing process: Knowing why you must write your book.

Enjoy!

Deborah


Start with Why, not What

By Esther Harder

Have you ever been at a social gathering and someone asks you what you do, so you admit to being a writer and are immediately hit with: “Oh! What do you write?” quickly followed by “What’s your book about?”

And then you likely proceed into that dreaded/blessed elevator pitch one-liner that you’ve practiced ad nauseum in the hopes that the response is: “Ooh! I would totally read that!”

In order to write that zinger of a hook that has strangers pulling out their wallets, you need to have done a whole lot of deep work. Not on what your book’s about, but on why you are writing the book in the first place.

I’m a book coach, and a big part of my job is to help writers slow down and step back from their plot to make sure their vision for their book—their publication goals, their audience, their message, their voice—is in alignment. I use a tool called the Blueprint to help writers create a strong foundation for their idea, so that the book they get onto the page more closely approximates the version they hold in their hearts.

The Blueprint starts with a huge WHY question: Why must you write this book? Note the verb choice there: MUST.

Not: Why do you want to write this book?

Or: Why do you think you should write this book?

Simply: Why must you write this book?

In order to write that zinger of a hook, you have to take a stand. You’ve got to claim this is something you must do. Because writing a book is hard. There are days that you’re going to sit at your desk, and everything within you is going to plead and push and whine and cajole and do all the things to convince you to get up out of that chair. If you don’t have the inner conviction that this is a thing you must do, you’re going to get up and go. Answering why tests your resolve: Better to know you aren’t 100% now and save yourself the frustration.

One of the challenges I witness with my memoir clients is that sometimes they come to me with lack of clarity around why they are writing. They may have started the project for fun, as a legacy for their children. And when they pass their work around, they receive such positive feedback that they begin to wonder if maybe their story could have a wider reach beyond their circle of friends.

This wonder is great. AND it nudges the writer beyond their initial contract with themselves.

When you begin with a goal of writing a legacy book, you’re writing for a specific audience—people who know and love you. And your must might be something along the lines of telling your story before that story gets lost. When you consider looking outward towards readers who don’t know you yet, your must has shifted. Readers who don’t know you are attuned to their own desires and attention spans; they don’t have a personal connection motivating them to read whatever you set in front of them.

Imagine a reader impassively picking up your book at a shop, scanning the cover, and setting it back down on the table without even reading the first sentence—such a gut punch! Now, knowing that’s the potential result, rewind yourself to before you write the first sentence and ask:

Why must you write this book anyway?

This inquiry process pushes you to identify your deep motivations. You can even break this question down word by word:

  • You: What’s in this story that only you can tell?
  • Must Write: What’s that driving force, your motivation to write?
  • This Book: What’s in this story that isn’t in other stories you could write? Why this book at this time?
  • Anyway: This is a bonus add-on. In the face of bad reviews, low sales, people setting your book down in a bookshop—why are you still convinced this is the book you want to write right now?

Does thinking about your work at this level make you a little queasy? Join the club! This is deep negotiating work. This is standing bravely in front of the dragon of doubt and telling yourself the blade you are holding is steel and not flimsy cardboard. This is practice for when you’re at that mixer where someone asks you what your book’s about and after you’ve given them the zinger, they give you a meh face and no follow-ups. This deep knowledge about your personal motivation for writing is the spine that keeps you standing and engaged in that conversation instead of melting into the floor.

Because their feeling about the book doesn’t add (or subtract) any value to the book. YOUR feeling about your work is what determines how you will value your book.

But Esther, you say, this process doesn’t sound like I am making any progress on actually writing my book. I’m just thinking about my feelings.

Yes, yes you are. This is a multiple-things-can-be-true situation. You are thinking about your feelings (and naming them and inhabiting them and channeling them) AND you are making progress on your book’s foundation.

Because the creative process is as much about our feelings and mindset towards our creations as it is about the creative act itself. As a book coach, a huge proportion of my work is mindset coaching. Because writers know how to get words onto the page. It’s getting the Self to show up and contribute in a positive way instead of hijacking the process that’s the bigger challenge. By addressing the feelings and identifying the deep motivation prompting the work, a writer can come to the page, whole and human, and has more potential to keep writing when the writing gets hard.

That’s what I’m coaching towards. And I would love for you to join me.


Esther Harder is a book coach who helps memoir writers with battered passports tell their story on their own terms. Sign up to receive six strategies for shifting your attention away from the inner critic that would keep you from writing and toward the inner cheerleader that will inspire you to keep going: Outsider Vibes.

And read more about Esther’s coaching over on Write Like An Outsider.